Palm Beach / Midtown & In-Town / Parcel map
Historical MLS sale · MLS R3315806
258 Pendleton Avenue, Palm Beach, FL 33480
This home is for sale now · asking $8,250,000 · See the current listing →
Sold 07/17/13 for $1,700,000 · $457 per living sq ft
Source: BeachesMLS · MLS reporting cutoff 11/18/26
- MLS #
- R3315806
- Status
- Closed — historical sale
- Sale date
- 07/17/13
- Sold price
- $1,700,000
- Price per living sq ft
- $457
- Original asking price
- $2,140,000
- Final asking price
- $1,890,000
- Sold price as a share of final asking
- 89.9%
- Listed
- 10/09/12
- Under contract
- 06/25/13
- Days from listing to contract
- 259 days
- Property type
- Single Family Residence
- Bedrooms
- 5
- Bathrooms
- 5.5
- Living area
- 3,721 sq ft
- Year built
- 1936
- Subdivision (tax)
- Palm Beach - In-Town
- Waterfront
- None
- Parcel ID
- 50434322010030011
- Listing brokerage
- The Corcoran Group
- Listing brokerage email
- marcia.vanzyl@corcoran.com
- Listing brokerage MLS ID
- 404289
How this sale compared
$457 per living sq ft · 259 days to contract · sold for $1,700,000
How this sale compared with several groups of Midtown & In-Town sales during the two years before it closed (07/17/11 to 07/17/13). Each row looks at one characteristic; these are not adjusted comparable valuations.
Below the median price per square foot in all 5 groups shown, and under contract faster than 3 of 5.
These comparisons don't explain why; condition, improvements and other differences need a closer look.
| Compared with | Median price per sq ft | Median days to contract | Sale-price rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole communityMidtown & In-Town68 other sales · 690 properties | $692based on 68 other sales | 215 daysbased on 68 other sales | 49th highest of 69 |
| StreetPendleton Avenue1 other sale · 21 properties | $493Based on one other sale | 1423 daysBased on one other sale | Lowest of 2 |
| Bedrooms4 bedrooms20 other sales · 198 properties | $727based on 20 other sales | 202 daysbased on 20 other sales | 17th highest of 21 |
| Living area3,000–3,999 living sq ft16 other sales · 168 properties | $698based on 16 other sales | 282 daysbased on 16 other sales | 15th highest of 17 |
| Year builtBuilt in the 1930s9 other sales · 72 properties | $580based on 9 other sales | 261 daysbased on 9 other sales | 9th highest of 10 |
The same groups of Midtown & In-Town sales during the past 12 months (11/19/25 to 11/18/26). This sale closed 07/17/13, before this window, so the rows show how these groups have sold since then; the sale-price rank appears only for windows that include the sale. Each row looks at one characteristic; these are not adjusted comparable valuations.
These comparisons don't explain why; condition, improvements and other differences need a closer look.
| Compared with | Median price per sq ft | Median days to contract | Sale-price rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole communityMidtown & In-Town33 other sales · 690 properties | $3,332based on 33 other sales | 78 daysbased on 31 other sales | – |
| StreetPendleton Avenue0 other sales · 21 properties | No other sales | – | – |
| Bedrooms4 bedrooms15 other sales · 198 properties | $3,225based on 15 other sales | 53 daysbased on 14 other sales | – |
| Living area3,000–3,999 living sq ft9 other sales · 168 properties | $3,225based on 9 other sales | 56 daysbased on 9 other sales | – |
| Year builtBuilt in the 1930s2 other sales · 72 properties | $2,832based on 2 other sales | 137 daysbased on 2 other sales | – |
The same groups of Midtown & In-Town sales during the past 24 months (11/19/24 to 11/18/26). This sale closed 07/17/13, before this window, so the rows show how these groups have sold since then; the sale-price rank appears only for windows that include the sale. Each row looks at one characteristic; these are not adjusted comparable valuations.
These comparisons don't explain why; condition, improvements and other differences need a closer look.
| Compared with | Median price per sq ft | Median days to contract | Sale-price rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole communityMidtown & In-Town66 other sales · 690 properties | $3,225based on 65 other sales | 102 daysbased on 64 other sales | – |
| StreetPendleton Avenue1 other sale · 21 properties | $3,217Based on one other sale | 763 daysBased on one other sale | – |
| Bedrooms4 bedrooms31 other sales · 198 properties | $3,165based on 31 other sales | 92 daysbased on 30 other sales | – |
| Living area3,000–3,999 living sq ft16 other sales · 168 properties | $3,217based on 15 other sales | 89 daysbased on 16 other sales | – |
| Year builtBuilt in the 1930s2 other sales · 72 properties | $2,832based on 2 other sales | 137 daysbased on 2 other sales | – |
The same groups of Midtown & In-Town sales during the past 36 months (11/19/23 to 11/18/26). This sale closed 07/17/13, before this window, so the rows show how these groups have sold since then; the sale-price rank appears only for windows that include the sale. Each row looks at one characteristic; these are not adjusted comparable valuations.
These comparisons don't explain why; condition, improvements and other differences need a closer look.
| Compared with | Median price per sq ft | Median days to contract | Sale-price rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whole communityMidtown & In-Town90 other sales · 690 properties | $3,217based on 89 other sales | 98 daysbased on 88 other sales | – |
| StreetPendleton Avenue1 other sale · 21 properties | $3,217Based on one other sale | 763 daysBased on one other sale | – |
| Bedrooms4 bedrooms38 other sales · 198 properties | $3,176based on 38 other sales | 91 daysbased on 37 other sales | – |
| Living area3,000–3,999 living sq ft21 other sales · 168 properties | $3,233based on 20 other sales | 112 daysbased on 21 other sales | – |
| Year builtBuilt in the 1930s6 other sales · 72 properties | $2,986based on 6 other sales | 118 daysbased on 6 other sales | – |
Groups follow the county property appraiser's records. Each median leaves out this sale and appears once the other sales reach 1% of the group's properties. A comparison describes the market at the time; it is not a valuation. Midtown & In-Town market report · How these are compared
Want a closer look at this sale?
David can walk through what may have set this sale apart, such as condition, updates and setting within Midtown & In-Town, and what it could mean for a property you own or are considering.
Other sales of this property
No other closed MLS sale of this parcel is in the saved dataset.
County tax record for this home
- Total market value
- $7,445,135
- Tax bill mailed to
- Florida
Sales recorded by the county
| Sale date | Sale price |
|---|---|
| 07/11/13 | $1,700,000 |
From the Palm Beach County tax roll, current to 07/24/26. The roll keeps its five most recent recorded sales; deeds under $10,000, such as a transfer into a trust, are not counted as sales. The total market value is the property appraiser's figure for tax purposes, not a sale price. Owner names are not shown.
These details describe this listing at the time of sale. Features, condition, ownership and subdivision labels may have changed since. This is a recorded closed MLS sale for this parcel in the saved dataset, which may not include every transaction.
