David AbernathyPalm Beach County market intelligence

Distinctive Communities / Steeplechase / Parcel map

Historical MLS sale · MLS R11147059

5255 Counter Play Road, Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33418

Sold 05/14/26 for $3,096,160 · $657 per living sq ft

Source: BeachesMLS · MLS reporting cutoff 10/30/26

MLS #
R11147059
Status
Closed — historical sale
Sale date
05/14/26
Sold price
$3,096,160
Price per living sq ft
$657
Original asking price
$4,199,000
Final asking price
$3,595,000
Sold price as a share of final asking
86.1%
Listed
02/10/26
Under contract
03/18/26
Days from listing to contract
36 days
Property type
Single Family Residence
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
3.5
Living area
4,711 sq ft
Year built
1994
Subdivision (tax)
Steeplechase
Parcel ID
52424223040120140
Listing brokerage
Leibowitz Realty Group, LLC./PBG
Listing brokerage email
michael@leibowitzrealty.com
Listing brokerage MLS ID
404730

How this sale compared

$657 per living sq ft · 36 days to contract · sold for $3,096,160

How this sale compared with several groups of Steeplechase sales during the two years before it closed (05/14/24 to 05/14/26). Each row looks at one characteristic; these are not adjusted comparable valuations.

Above the median price per square foot in 3 of 4 groups shown, and under contract faster than all 4 groups shown.

These comparisons don't explain why; condition, improvements and other differences need a closer look.

Compared withMedian price per sq ftMedian days to contractSale-price rank
Whole communitySteeplechase25 other sales · 316 properties$622based on 25 other sales53.5 daysbased on 24 other sales11th highest of 26
StreetCounter Play Road0 other sales · 9 propertiesNo other sales–Only sale
Bedrooms5 or more bedrooms14 other sales · 96 properties$628based on 14 other sales68 daysbased on 13 other sales8th highest of 15
Living area4,000–5,999 living sq ft13 other sales · 127 properties$719based on 13 other sales64.5 daysbased on 12 other sales9th highest of 14
Year builtBuilt in the 1990s8 other sales · 153 properties$527based on 8 other sales71 daysbased on 8 other sales3rd highest of 9

Groups follow the county property appraiser's records. Each median leaves out this sale and appears once the other sales reach 1% of the group's properties. A comparison describes the market at the time; it is not a valuation. Steeplechase market report · How these are compared

Want a closer look at this sale?

David can walk through what may have set this sale apart, such as condition, updates and setting within Steeplechase, and what it could mean for a property you own or are considering.

Ask David about this sale ↗︎

Other sales of this property

Sale dateSold priceMLS #
08/29/19$1,900,000R10506341

These details describe this listing at the time of sale. Features, condition, ownership and subdivision labels may have changed since. This is a recorded closed MLS sale for this parcel in the saved dataset, which may not include every transaction.